This pioneering legislation made eias mandatory in the united states which, in turn, contributed to the accelerated development of eia. Many consultants worked on the feasibility studies of this dam and have provided much information on the merits and demerits of. Regrettably, when the need is for broadbased stakeholder consultations, the existing trend is. The construction of proposed kalabagh dam evokes strong opposition in. Although this perception is not directly related to kalabagh dam project, i have included it to clear the air of mistrust related with the formation of one unit and signing of indus water treaty. Chairman wapda has said that no work on kalabagh dam will start unless consensus is developed among the provinces, and proposed if kalabagh dam is.
The kalabagh dam is a huge and costly multipurpose project. An examination of the kalabagh dam controversy environmental. Kalabagh dam on list of ready for construction projects. However, on 26 may 2008, the federal minister for water and power of pakistan, raja pervez ashraf, said that the kalabagh dam would not be constructed and that the project had. The national environmental policy act of the united states or nepa became operational only in 1971.
According to the plans will have a height of 1 feet and its lake will cover an area of 164 square miles. Construction of kalabagh dam background paper 170611. A key reason has to do with the decision making process, which is highly centralized, politically coercive, and technically flawed. Why sardar sarovar dam has faced protests like jal. Kalabagh dam 1 kalabagh dam irfan arshad ir department university of sargodha pakistan 2 introduction. The nation has done a service to its readers by publishing two articles at a time, one for and the other against on the kalabagh dam april 18, 97. Hydro politics and interprovincial relations in pakistan a case study of the kalabagh dam controversy usman muhammad master thesis, 30 hec, uppsala 2012 rural development and natural resource management masters programme department of urban and rural development. Kalabagh dam controversy resurfaces in senate pakistan. The dam site is linked by a railway line and road which are passing near a distance of approximately. Its main focus will be to provide electricity, and water for irrigation. Says concerns of sindh, kp about project have already been addressed.
Since 1984, when the kalabagh dam controversy was given an ethnic and provincial colour till today, pakistans water predicament has. The chief justice said that kalabagh dam will be built at any cost adding, i do not know if this dam will be constructed in my life or not but the superior court will make the very first. Four indian states, gujarat, madhya pradesh, maharashtra and rajasthan, receive water and electricity supplied from the dam. In pakistan, as the kalabagh dam project became politicized, the engineers employed by provincial irrigation departments whose experience and knowledge was not directly related with building dams were used to question the technical details of the project.
The kalabagh dam is controversial for many reasons. The foundation stone of the project was laid out by prime minister jawaharlal nehru on 5 april 1961. Jun 14, 2018 kalabagh dam is technically viable, say wapda chief. The construction of proposed kalabagh dam evokes strong opposition in some parts of the country while. Kalabagh dam free download as powerpoint presentation. Without the dam, the long term costs for people would be much greater and lack of an income source for future generations would put increasing pressure on the environment. Hydro politics and interprovincial relations in pakistan.
Jun 06, 2018 in december 2004, then president of pakistan general pervez musharraf announced that he would build the dam to serve the larger interest of pakistan. We can discern it from the fact that almost everywhere, there are communities or groups of activists organising against the proposed building of a dam, in their. Kalabagh dam issue the kalabagh dam is proposed to be built across the indus about 120 miles southwest of islamabad, some 16 miles from soan river. Kalabagh dam is technically viable, say wapda chief. Ethiopian engineer of controversial renaissance dam found dead. Mangla dam, embankment dam on the jhelum river near jhelum, pakistan. Lakhwarvyasi dam project on yamuna river, includes underconstruction lakhwar dam and power station, vyasi dam, hathiari power station and katapathar barrage, near the lakhwar town in kalsi block of dehradun district of uttarakhand in india, for the purpose of irrigation of 40,000 hectare land and total 927 mw hydroelectric power generation. The kalabagh dam kbd has been turned into a touchy subject as controversies and differences of. Only technical criteria such as height and storage volume are used for this classification. It is expected to provide power and water to 9,000 villages in. Tvp editorial march 28, 2010 environment 0 comments. Kallanai dam news latest news on kallanai dam times of. After commissioning of tarbela dam in 1976, the dam could have been built in six years by 1982.
Located at a distance of 15 km from tiruchirapalli, the dam was originally constructed by the chola kingkarikala around the 2nd century ad. If constructed, the dam could generate 3,600 mw of electricity, but is also promoted as a potential. Plans to build the kalabagh dam on the indus river have been the source of tensions between regional provinces in pakistan for more than thirty years. The sardar sarovar dam, on the narmada river, is the worlds second largest dam after the grand coulee dam in the united states. The sardar sarovar is the biggest dam on the river and its construction has been fiercely opposed. A threemember bench of the apex court, headed by the cjp heard the kalabagh dam case. Kalabagh dam has always been a source of great controversy and has always aroused emotions. Kalabagh dam which can come on stream the earliest is no longer a matter of choice, it is a matter of survival of the country.
Kalabagh dam dam hydroelectricity free 30day trial. The cost per unit of 12 billion units, the kbd hydel electricity was rs1. Since 1984, when the kalabagh dam controversy was given an ethnic and provincial colour till today, pakistans water predicament has worsened. It is hated by those weaned on the staple diet of visceral anger pandering more to prejudice than logic. However, very cleverly it is not contested as an engineering or technical issue rather it is presented as a political issue in which wapda. The sardar sarovar dam is a gravity dam on the narmada river near navagam, gujarat in india. Sep 17, 2017 the sardar sarovar dam, on the narmada river, is the worlds second largest dam after the grand coulee dam in the united states. Kalabagh dam will be built at any cost, remarks cjp saqib. Aug 21, 2017 kalabagh dam is to be an earth fill 265 feet high, with water reservoir capacity of 6. Kalabagh dam pakistan, advantages disadvantages and objections part 2 make kalabagh dam pakistan in this video you see what is kala bag dam and why is important for pakistan. Kalabagh dam, six other water reservoirs being planned. Muhammad feyyaz, who holds a masters degree in w ar studies from quaideazam university, islamabad and m. The dam was originally built by karikala chola around first century ad.
Chairman wapda has said that no work on kalabagh dam will start unless consensus is developed among the provinces, and proposed if kalabagh dam is built, then give its operational. Sep 22, 2010 kalabagh dam which can come on stream the earliest is no longer a matter of choice, it is a matter of survival of the country. Bhakra dam on sutlej river has storage capacity of 5. Jun 22, 2018 kalabagh dam dilemma the frontier post june 22, 2018 one of the burring and most debated issues in print and electronic media now a day is the opposition to the construction of kalabagh dam, ignoring an informed discussion on its merits and demerits. By some estimates, there are 47,000 large dams in the world.
Two glaring examples to prove my point should suffice 1 sui gas has. Apart from the above effort on the part of the government, the print media has a pivotal role in educating public opinion on the pros and cons of dams and on kalabagh dam in particular. Kalabagh dam dilemma the frontier post june 22, 2018 one of the burring and most debated issues in print and electronic media now a day is the opposition to the construction of kalabagh dam, ignoring an informed discussion on its merits and demerits. Introduction the kalabagh dam site is located about 194 km ds of tarbela dam and 16 km us of kalabagh town. Pakistan, after the elections, is once again faced with perhaps the most divisive political issue the construction of the kalabagh dam. The controversy regarding the kalabagh dam could be a result of lack of relevant information and distrust among the provinces. Kalabagh dam, slope stability, slide, contouring, elevations 1. The punjab government on wednesday resumed the construction work on the shahpurkandi dam project, after due assessment on the ground with respect to labour availability at.
Kalabagh dam pakistan, advantages disadvantages and. Oct 14, 2015 kalabagh dam, six other water reservoirs being planned. One of the many expectations from the pakistan muslim leaguenawaz pmln is to bring to life the kalabagh dam. Jun 04, 2018 kalabagh dam pakistan, advantages disadvantages and objections part 2 make kalabagh dam pakistan in this video you see what is kala bag dam and why is important for pakistan. This project was conceived in 1992, approved in 1996 and construction began in 1999. Mar 12, 2012 the controversy of the aswan high dam y. Many in pakistan are supportive of the kalabagh project, as this dam will help to utilise surplus water of the river indus and it happens to be one of the most investigated projects in the world. Baglihar bandh, also known as baglihar hydroelectric power project, is a runoftheriver power project on the chenab river in the ramban district of the indian union territory of jammu and kashmir. Last month, a sixmember team comprising officials from two national political parties and independent experts conducted a factfinding tour to. Nov 16, 2000 the sardar sarovar is the biggest dam on the river and its construction has been fiercely opposed. Mangla dam, completed in 1967, is one of the main structures in the indus basin project another is tarbela dam when it was completed, the dam structure rose 453 feet 8 metres above ground level, was about 10,300 feet 3,140 metres wide at its crest, and had a volume of 85.
Kalabagh dam is to be an earth fill 265 feet high, with water reservoir capacity of 6. Kalabagh dam is the most feasible project from all aspects, less time for construction, feasibility is ready, site is ready, detailed study is completed, can generate 3500 mw, on top of all these. Apart from the above effort on the part of the government, the print media has a pivotal role in educating public opinion on the pros and cons of. Combines pdf files, views them in a browser and downloads. However, till now nobody including the government has had the balls to call an open national debate on the pros and cons of the project and allowed the parlimentarians to openly debate the issue. History, map and issues hamza 07062018 kalabagh dam issue is an issue which you cant take eyes off, thanks to pcrwrs latest report which states that if there comes no serious efforts pakistan will run out of the water by 2025.
Done b 2 ally sia dee uang 3 6 1 pe anne h 1 jeanet te c slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. Today big dams are one of the key concerns of the environmentalists across the world. Kalabagh dam is among the proposed dams in pakistan since 1987. Pakistan is already one of the most waterstressed countries in the world, a situation which is going to degrade into outright water scarcity due to high population growth. It is a good way of evolving general consensus on current controversial national issues. Opposition senators stage walkout to protest govts apathy towards mina tragedy victims. Kalabagh dam which will increase the water resources of the country is being opposed while thar coal project, which will consume a huge amount of water and will contaminate all water, air and land resources of pakistan is being advocated by the. The controversy of the aswan high dam linkedin slideshare. India had 4,635 large dams as per icold definition.
May 29, 20 many in pakistan are supportive of the kalabagh project, as this dam will help to utilise surplus water of the river indus and it happens to be one of the most investigated projects in the world. Kalabagh dam is one of the most hated dams in the country. Ppt kalabagh dam powerpoint presentation free to download. Kallanai dam news latest news on kallanai dam times of india. In downstream sindh province, politicians have described the dam as a water theft by the province of punjab, where the dam is planned to be built dawn, 2018. Mar 28, 2010 where tehri dam project drew protest from the villagers of uttaranchal and the issue was used as effective votebank tool in the assembly polls of 2006, the tipaimukh dam project is facing protests from the manipur and the northeast bangladeshi peoples as, its being referred as another farakka, the dam which created much controversy during. Islamabad 92 news chief justice of pakistan cjp justice mian saqib nisar on wednesday, while hearing the kalabagh dam case, remarked that kalabagh dam will be constructed at any cost. The punjab government on wednesday resumed the construction work on the shahpurkandi dam project, after due assessment.
942 795 561 312 1010 123 1423 168 920 993 294 473 839 79 1578 1440 1150 615 974 343 808 1404 1118 515 973 419 746 810 1556 126 353 1202 859 156 1575 102 390 688 74 170 1034 704 1196 299 290 1266 263 1063